Winter Rose and Ella Enchanted


There is something gnarled and bramble-y about Winter Rose. Patricia A McKillip dreamily draws out something deep, romantic and a little magical in her retelling of Tam Lin.

Rois, who looks nothing like a Rose, whose “skin is not fit for fairy tales” sees Corbet Lynn walk out of the light, a blur of gold:

“I turned, walked into the hot noon light, and saw him, with his pale gold hair and light-filled eyes, riding his horse the color of buttermilk across the green grass, as if he were human as the rest of us, not something that had stepped out of light into time. I could not move; I could not breathe. And then, as if he read my thoughts, his eyes met mine. Pale green seemed to melt through me, and I thought: How could they be any other color?”

Rois is obsessed with Corbet and his past – his grandfather was murdered by his own son and laid a wicked curse “You are the last of us and you will die the last: As many as you have, your children will never be your own”. So then who is Corbet Lynn and why does he appear in Rois’ intoxicating dreams?

Her language can be a tad flowery so it is not for everyone. But when I read her words, I hear this voice in my head, a whispery, echoey kind of voice, the kind of voice that sounds as if spoken in an ageing castle. The writer sits with a goblet of wine, a quill resting on the paper. A heavy rug is underfoot for it is the depths of winter and snow is ever so quietly falling outside. A fire is roaring and crackling, breaking the stillness.

Her book, her words are so very dreamy, I drift off into her dark world where curses are laid and enchantments are made. And it is difficult to emerge from her wintery world and into the bright sunshine, colourful toys around, decorations from the party still hanging, kids napping upstairs.


The Cinderella adaptation Ella Enchanted is such a very different read. Things move at a faster clip and the language is far simpler and less descriptive. It is still a rather entertaining story, at times a little silly (which would make its intended audience giggle – OK so I did too), and just such a fun read. I mean, how could a fairy’s blessing become such a pain?

Well it can if the blessing is obedience, leaving the poor child condemned to obey every order she’s given, even if it’s something as simple as “eat”.

A short but very satisfactory read with a strong-spirited and intelligent lead character and a refreshing retelling of the Cinderella tale.

At first I wondered if I had seen the movie version but then I realised it was the image of Drew Barrymore in Ever After that kept popping into my head – Anne Hathaway stars in Ella Enchanted so said the Internet. And the consensus (at least on Goodreads) seems to be that one should stay far away from the Ella Enchanted movie. I’ll be heeding that advice, but if you’ve watched it, was it really that bad?



Winter Rose and Ella Enchanted were my second and third reads for Once Upon A Time VIII.



  1. The movie version of Ella Enchanted is silly. It’s also the reason why I want to read the book. If everyone is saying to stay away from the movie, then the book must be much better. ๐Ÿ™‚ Winter Rose sounds amazing.


  2. I haven’t seen Ella Enchanted and in fact hadn’t realised there was a book (silly me!) Will have to look at this one and also Winter Rose which sounds really good – I can see I’ll have a massive list for next year’s event!
    Lynn ๐Ÿ˜€


  3. Ella Enchanted is definitely light and silly, but it’s so much fun–and I like the core elements of a strong heroine who has to decide what to make of her life. One of my favorite Cinderella retellings!
    And yes. The movie really is that bad. Really.
    Well…I’ve been TOLD that it’s an okay movie if you look at it as completely separate from the book. I can’t really say, because I spent the whole time shrieking “no, no, that’s WRONG!!” It’s not so much that they changed aspects of the plot, it’s that it was a complete travesty on the whole style and feel of the book, taking a light, sweet story and making it ridiculous.
    Ahem. I’ll move on…


    1. It sounds like one of those movie adaptations that should be seen before reading the book! Then it’ll be the reaction of “Oh it’s an ok movie”. And then ‘wow that’s an even better book”. Seriously though, with all the reactions to the movie, I am rather curious now hahaha!


      1. That’s how I felt–I watched it out of morbid curiosity because people kept telling me it was terrible. I don’t know if I regret watching it, exactly (at least now I know!) but…yeah. So bad!


  4. I was introduced to Ella Enchanted through the film. It’s not a bad film, as such, but… Well, Cheryl pretty much captures it ^_^ I think it’s a fun film in its own right (or at least I enjoyed it), but if you’re going into it expecting a fairly faithful adaptation you’ll end up sorely disappointed. I’d have hated it if I’d read the book first.

    And I love that description of Winter Rose. I hope you’re having fun with the OuaT reading!


Comments are closed.